Quick answer
Use the smallest mass-gainer portion that creates a modest calorie surplus, then adjust from two to three weeks of average weight and waist trends. Do not start with the manufacturer's giant serving. We prefer a homemade whey-and-oats shake because calories are easier to control; split commercial servings when convenience wins.
Why mass gainers lead to fat gain for most people
The most common mistake with mass gainers is consuming them on top of an already adequate diet without adjusting food intake elsewhere. A mass gainer shake delivering 800 calories on top of a 2,600-calorie diet produces a 3,400-calorie day, well above what most people need for muscle building.
The shake itself is not the problem. Untracked excess calories are. A mass gainer only causes fat gain when total daily intake exceeds what your body can use for energy, recovery and muscle building.
Live comparison
Mass Gainer products
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000124 £27.99 50.4g1029£1.166 3000114 £24.99 50.4g1029£1.785 2000110 £16.99 50.4g1029£1.699 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 4000132 £25.99 28.0g479£0.812 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000137 £39.99 28.0g460£1.081 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000118 £44.99 53.0g1059£2.499 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 8480132 £82.49 50.4g1006£2.578 4240116 £46.99 50.4g1006£2.937 212018 £26.49 50.4g1006£3.311 132515 £19.99 53.0g992£3.998 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000132 £54.99 43.0g572£1.718 2500116 £29.99 43.0g572£1.874 100016 £12.99 43.0g572£2.165 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 2500125 £29.99 31.0g369£1.200 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 8000140 £107.49 50.0g769£2.687 4000120 £59.99 50.0g769£3.000 2000110 £34.99 50.0g769£3.499 100015 £19.99 50.0g769£3.998 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000159 £68.99 37.0g314£1.169 2500129 £37.99 37.0g314£1.310 1000112 £16.99 37.0g314£1.416 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 2721.5518 £38.00 46.0g1225£4.750 997.913 £18.00 46.0g1225£6.000 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5450116 £82.00 50.0g1260£5.125 273018 £50.00 50.0g1260£6.250 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 3200130 £49.95 25.4g401£1.665 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 2740110 £45.99 50.0g1000£4.599 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 2267.9618 £39.00 56.0g1100£4.875 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 5000150 £98.49 29.0g383£1.970 2500125 £51.99 29.0g378£2.080 1000110 £20.99 29.0g378£2.099 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 3150130 £69.95 30.0g400£2.332 |
FlavourSize (g)QtyServingsOfferTotal Per serving 2500120 £57.99 33.0g451£2.900 |
Calculate your actual calorie target first
Before using a mass gainer, establish your maintenance calories and your target surplus. A surplus of 200-350 calories above maintenance is sufficient for muscle growth in most people past the beginner stage.
Once you know your target, the mass gainer is simply a tool to reach it. If your maintenance is 2,500 calories and your target is 2,800, the mass gainer shake needs to fit within that 2,800, not sit on top of it. If the shake provides 800 calories, the rest of your diet must be planned around that number.
Use partial servings
Most mass gainer products give serving size recommendations on the label, but those servings are often designed for the largest calorie needs, athletes in two-a-day training or people who genuinely need 4,000 calories per day. For most buyers, a half-serving is more practical.
Mixing half the recommended powder into a shake gives you 300-500 calories and 20-30g of protein with more flexibility to fill the remainder of your caloric target through whole food. This also tends to be easier on digestion.
Community perspective
What others are saying
Use some homemade mass gainer shakes in between meals. 2 of those can get you an extra 1800 calories in a day. So if you are eating 2,000 calories now. Throwing 2 of those shakes in will get you to 3800.
u/PatrioticBro in r/Fitness
See how the protein goes if anything take the protein after workouts and still use a mass gainer for the mornings! Def worth a shot since the protein will help get your macros but the mass gainer will increase your calorie intake massively. Ayyy!!! Shoutout to your friend, Ye is the 🐐
u/brownyewest in r/Fitness
Watch what buyers found
Hands-on opinions
How To Bulk Like A Pro (Using Science)
Jeff Nippard
A topic-specific video selected for additional practical context on How to Use Mass Gainer without Getting Fat: A Practical Step-by-Step Guide.
Prioritise resistance training
The surplus calories from a mass gainer will be directed toward muscle synthesis only if there is a training stimulus demanding it. Without resistance training, the calories have nowhere useful to go and are stored as fat.
Progressive overload training, consistently increasing the demand on muscles through heavier weights, more volume or greater intensity over time, is what creates the signal for your body to build muscle with the available calories. The mass gainer supports the process; it does not replace the training.
Cheapest Mass Gainer
Pure Source Nutrition Hard Gainer Powder
Pure Source Nutrition · 2kg
Pros
- Maltodextrin and dextrose dissolve readily, while oat flour and waxy maize add body; the 210g serving should mix smoother than an all-oat gainer but much thicker than whey
- 38% below the £1.37/100g average across 17 comparable /compare listings
Cons
- A 210g serving contains 42g sugar; sucralose and Dextralose add further sweetness, so Banana is likely to finish much sweeter than a banana-and-oats shake
- Xanthan gum thickens 210g of powder in only 500–600ml liquid, so it needs the stated 30-second shake and will become heavier if left to stand
Track and adjust weekly
Weigh yourself at the same time three to four days per week and calculate a weekly average. Gaining 0.2-0.5kg per week is a reasonable rate for an intermediate lifter in a clean bulk phase. More than this and fat gain is likely accelerating. Reduce the mass gainer serving or total daily intake. Less than this and the surplus is too small.
If you are gaining weight but strength and performance in training are also improving, the bulk is working. If weight is going up but training performance is stagnant, the calories are not being utilised effectively and the training programme may need reviewing.
Do not use a mass gainer if you do not need extra calories
The simplest way to use a mass gainer without getting fat is to not use one unless your calorie needs genuinely require it. If you can hit your target surplus through whole food comfortably, a mass gainer adds complexity without benefit.
Whey protein and food is sufficient for the majority of people building muscle. Mass gainers are a solution to a specific problem, not enough calories, and should only be introduced when that problem actually exists.
References
Sources and further reading
- 01ProteinDeals — live product comparison
Current product, nutrition and retailer data used for the article's buying context.
Frequently asked questions
How many scoops of mass gainer per day should I take?+
Enough to hit your daily calorie target without exceeding it. Start with a half-serving, track how it fits into your total intake, and adjust from there. The label's serving suggestion is a maximum, not a minimum.
Should I take a mass gainer every day?+
If your daily calorie target requires it, yes. Total weekly calorie balance is what drives weight change, so consistency across every day, including rest days, is important for a predictable bulk.
Can I replace meals with a mass gainer?+
Technically yes, but it is not ideal. Whole food meals provide micronutrients, fibre and satiety that mass gainer powder does not replicate. Use it to supplement meals and fill calorie gaps, not replace structured eating.






















