The only metric that actually matters
Tub price is almost useless as a comparison tool. A 2.5kg bag at £45 and a 1kg bag at £22 look completely different until you divide by weight. Then factor in that one product is 80g protein per 100g and the other is 72g, and the cheaper-looking tub becomes the worse deal.
Cost per gram of protein (pack price divided by total weight divided by protein percentage) is the only number that lets you compare whey concentrate, isolate, vegan blends and mass gainers on a fair basis. Everything else is marketing.
The live comparison tables on ProteinDeals calculate this automatically for every product in the database. Use those. The purpose of this guide is to explain what you are looking at when you get there.
Whey concentrate: still the default best value
Whey concentrate typically runs 70–82g protein per 100g. In large bags (2.5kg–5kg) from Bulk, Myprotein or own-label retailers, it consistently produces the lowest cost per gram of protein in the market, often between 2.5p and 3.5p per gram when a reasonable promotion is running.
The case against concentrate is lactose content and slightly lower protein density compared with isolate. For most people training recreationally and hitting 130–180g protein per day, neither is a real problem. If you are lactose intolerant or specifically cutting calories, isolate is worth the extra cost. If you are not, concentrate is almost always the smarter buy.
One thing worth watching is serving size manipulation. Some brands set a scoop to 25g to show a lower per-serving calorie count. Others use 40g scoops. Always check the per-100g column on the nutrition label, not the per-serving column.
Vegan protein: what the blends are actually doing
Single-source vegan protein like straight pea, soy, or rice typically has an incomplete amino acid profile or a suboptimal leucine content relative to whey. Pea protein is high in most essential amino acids but lower in methionine. Rice protein is the opposite. Blending them fixes both gaps.
The best vegan protein products in 2026 are pea-and-rice blends, which come close to matching whey's amino acid distribution. Look for products with at least 2.5g leucine per serving, as leucine is the primary trigger for muscle protein synthesis.
On value, vegan protein now sits roughly 10–20% more expensive per gram of protein than whey concentrate, down from a much wider gap three years ago. The category has become genuinely competitive. For anyone on a plant-based diet, a good pea-rice blend at a strong discount is a sensible buy.
Mass gainers: most are poor value, some are not
Mass gainers are protein powder plus carbohydrate — usually maltodextrin or oats — to increase the calorie count per serving. The protein content is typically 25–40g per serving with 60–100g carbohydrates, putting total calories at 400–700 per shake.
Most are poor value on a per-gram-of-protein basis because you are paying for carbohydrate filler. You can replicate the same macros more cheaply by mixing whey concentrate with oats or milk. Convenience is the only real reason to buy a mass gainer rather than building the same macros yourself.
That said, some mass gainers are priced aggressively enough to be worth it. Compare price per 100g and check protein percentage. Anything below 20g protein per 100g of powder is mostly carbs. Anything above 30g is a reasonable mass gainer. Above 35g puts it close to a blended protein.
Which brands are worth buying from in 2026
Bulk and Myprotein dominate the UK budget segment and between them cover almost every format. Bulk currently has the better whey value on standard pricing and a lower free-delivery threshold (£39 vs Myprotein's £50). Myprotein wins on flavour variety, clearance deals and the occasional aggressive promotion.
PhD, Optimum Nutrition and USN sit in a mid-tier where packaging and brand reputation are priced in. You are paying above commodity rates. The product quality is fine but the value case is harder to make if pure protein-per-pound is your metric.
Own-label and lesser-known brands sometimes produce the strongest value numbers in the live comparison tables because they do not carry marketing overhead. They are worth considering if the protein percentage and price per gram check out, since the formulas for whey concentrate are not secret.
The safest approach is to use the live rankings, sort by cost per gram of protein, check that the product has a sensible protein percentage (above 70g per 100g for concentrate, above 80g for isolate), and buy the one near the top that you will actually use consistently.